Tampa Bay Rays Stadium Bedlam

Cathedrals of the Game

In the spectrum of not-so-breaking news, Tampa Bay Rays ownership is not a huge fan of their team playing at Tropicana Field, America’s favorite giant warehouse. They’ve done all that they can to make the facility adequate, but it just does not invoke an ideal baseball atmosphere said owner Stuart Sternberg.

In 2008, then-St. Petersburg Mayor Rick Baker established a group called the ABC Coalition. The coalition’s job was to determine whether or not the Rays needed a new stadium, and they quickly decided that it was necessary. Their job then became finding the three best sites where a proposed stadium could possibly be built.

This is where they went from simple focus group to controversial entity.

Today, the ABC Coalition will meet with the Pinellas County Commission to discuss the three sites that they find most suitable for a stadium that has not even come close to being agreed upon yet. The part of this that sparks controversy is that two out of the three sites that they will discuss are located in neighboring Hillsborough County (read: Tampa for those of you unfamiliar with the area).

The Howard Frankland Bridge: 2010's Mason-Dixon Line

The Rays happen to be on one end of a contract that promises that they will play in the city of St. Petersburg until 2027. Let the technical evaluations begin.

I’ve heard many of the business explanations of this deal and honestly do not understand the vast majority of them. This is why I have simplified the scenario down to common language.

  • The Rays are under contract to play in St. Petersburg until 2027, but teams break contracts like this all the time often leading to messy lawsuits.
  • Rays ownership has said that the team simply cannot play at Tropicana Field for the remainder of this contract.
  • The Rays draw some of the worst attendance in MLB playing in St. Petersburg.
  • Tampa has roughly 100,000 more residents than St. Petersburg, but St. Petersburg officials almost seem more willing to let the Rays leave the state than cross the Howard Frankland Bridge.
  • Charlotte, North Carolina, would really like a baseball team.

Now to even have this debate, one has to first assume that the Rays actually need a new stadium.

While Tropicana Field has been dubbed a league-wide laughing stock, it is actually not that terrible of a place. It is a comfortable environment for watching a game during the blistering Florida summers. The fact that the stadium is indoors attracts snickers from many, but also guarantees spectators that they will see a game after they make the 30-minute trek from Tampa. Yes, a retractable roof would be nice, but the Trop was built in 1990 and it’s not called SkyDome.

This does not cause a rain delay. Advantage: Trop.

So maybe the main reason to build a new stadium is to appease the owners and keep the Rays in the area all while increasing team profits to supplement a more consistently competitive payroll. A more convenient location would be nice as well. The Glazer family did this same thing with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers when they bought the team in 1995 and it worked with the Tampa populace. Residents voted in favor of building Raymond James Stadium largely out of fear that the Bucs would leave town.

However, the Rays do not have nearly the civic support that the Bucs had at their similar juncture. St. Petersburg is an older community that is made almost entirely of northern transplant residents (read: Yankees and Red Sox fans). When news first surfaced that the Rays wanted to build a stadium that would likely use public finances, there was complete outrage.

Old folks protested outside of city hall in their favorite northeastern team gear and chanted for the Rays to please leave town. Hardly the bandwagon effect that Sternberg and friends were looking for.

But none of this was enough evidence for St. Petersburg politicians to admit that maybe their town wasn’t the best place for the Rays. When Hillsborough County Commissioner Ken Hagan invited the ABC Coalition to speak with the Hillsborough County Commission, St. Petersburg officials went into panic mode. Hagan tried to explain that he was more interested in making sure that the Rays do not leave the Tampa Bay area all together than he was claiming the team for Tampa, but the Pinellas suits generally didn’t listen.

However, if they looked around they wouldn’t have much trouble understanding why the Rays belong in Tampa.

St. Petersburg is a nice spring training town. So are Bradenton, Sarasota and Port Charlotte, but you won’t see anybody throwing those towns professional franchises anytime soon.

Sarasota: Beautiful, but not quite ready for the big time.

During their 2008 World Series runner-up season, the Rays averaged 22,259 fans per game, or a 52.8 percent attendance average. During a 2008-2009 campaign where they were among the worst teams in hockey, the Tampa Bay Lightning drew an average attendance of 16,497, or an 85.6 percent attendance average. The Lightning play their home games in downtown Tampa, one of the ABC Coalition’s three favorite locations.

If bad hockey can draw, good baseball will have no problem. Having a team in Tampa increases the sales of business season tickets which makes attendance a more consistent statistic. The Rays currently rely very heavily on walk-up crowds for most games.

Hockey in Tampa. An unlikely success.

There is of course the argument that no one city in the Tampa Bay area can supplement a major professional franchise by itself. However, just because that may be true doesn’t mean that it’s not more fiscally wise to place teams closer to the region’s major center of economy. When the Tampa Bay Rowdies became Tampa’s first professional sports franchise in 1975, they adopted the “Tampa Bay” distinction so that they would represent the entire Bay Area instead of just Tampa. That theory has since stuck, but it does not mean that Tampa isn’t the primary money-maker of the community.

The New England Patriots represent all of New England, but the Patriots play right outside of Boston, not in Maine.

This chaos will likely not have a clean ending. However, if the Rays end up moving to Charlotte instead of downtown Tampa or the Florida State Fairgrounds (where a $1 billion sports/entertainment complex is being discussed), than all fingers can be pointed across the Howard Frankland to St. Petersburg.

Hard Rock Hotel and Casino, conveniently located next to the fairgrounds.

Come on, Pinellas. Do it for the community.



Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “Tampa Bay Rays Stadium Bedlam

  1. Couldn’t have explained it better myself, if there really is an explanation beyond a bunch of blowhard egotists who won’t be caught dead doing what’s in the best interest of the community instead of their own political careers. Let the Rays leave St. Pete? Political suicide. Let them stay and build a stadium in current economic conflagration? Political suicide. St. Pete residents have the right to feel they don’t want to build a stadium right now for a bunch of fat cat baseball owners (yes, you’re right, my heart is not bleeding for them), especially after seeing how the Glazers took advantage of their stadium deal with Tampa (I’m a Tampa resident) and teachers in Pinellas County have already been let go and more to come. However, for the sake of discussion, I like the Rays and would love to have them come to Tampa but we’re in no better a situation than Pinellas economically. We do have the political and sports will, and that counts for a lot. I guess St. Pete will always have The Arts and the liberal politics and we get….Sports!!!

    • bholt11

      Thanks for reading and very good points.

      I’m not a fan of Tampa getting stuck with the public funding bill on a new stadium either, but Tampa is the only place where such a bill has a chance of passing. The Rays have zero civic support in St. Pete and will never get a stadium passed in Pinellas. I don’t blame residents for being against a new stadium tax, but I guarantee you that many of those same people would be all for a stadium tax to, say, bring Red Sox spring training to a new St. Pete park.

      Tampa isn’t in great shape economically to take the team, but that will probably end up being the only chance of keeping the Rays in the area. Few things make an area look more amateur than losing a professional sports franchise. Once we got past the initial economic troubles, having the Rays in Tampa would be great for the city.

      • Mike

        Sorry — have to disagree. The problem, no matter where you put the stadium, is the transplant population. It won’t matter if you put them in Tampa. The Lightning were competing the first half of the season and were fighting for the last playoff spot and I was at a game with only 12,000 people, most of whom were Canadians wearing their home jerseys. And lest you forget — their are over 900,000 people in Pinellas County — not just the residents St. Petersburg. Bottom line — put yourself in St. Pete’s shoes. The ONLY thing they are doing is requesting that the team honor their contract and their word. Now — if they want to break the contract, fine — I hope the team, MLB, and the whining residents of Hillsborough County (who can’t drive over a frickin bridge to see game — REAL fans drive much further in other cities) are willing to open up their checkbooks to compensate the taxpayers of Pinellas County for the hundreds of millions of dollars spent to attract a team to the BAY area (don’t recall Hillsborough thinking “regionally” when it came time to pay for the Trop, but now you want Pinellas to do the same), as well as the 100-150 million per year impact that the old, crappy Devil Rays were estimated to have on the Pinellas County economy. To make a long story short — if you want them so bad Tampa – show me the money. If not — how about showing some concern about keeping the team in the ‘region’ and driving across the bridge and going to a few games.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s