NFL Cities That Suck (And A Few That Don’t)

Hey, you got drafted! Now move here.

The first wave of rookie mini camps has concluded. Let’s talk about the cities that these shiny new millionaires are moving to.   

It’s the greatest day of your young football-related life. You’re a 22-year-old pro football prospect and you have worked your ass off your entire life for this moment. The NFL Draft is here, and you are about to be rewarded with a large enough signing bonus to buy your hometown and a symbol of status that will last a lifetime.   

And then the phone call comes. “Hey, it’s Chan Gailey. How do you feel about being a Buffalo Bill?”   

Buffalo. Buffalo. Freaking Buffalo.   

It is then that you realize just how many cities in the illustrious NFL absolutely suck. The following is my completely biased evaluation of every NFL city. Keep in mind that this is coming from the perspective of a Florida kid who has never been to the vast majority of the cities listed and gets cold when the temperature drops below 75 degrees. Basically this is just me throwing around shallow judgments. Enjoy!   

The thoughts and opinions below do not represent those of Robbie Hilson. Sometimes I stretch the wildly entertaining, mildly offensive thing a bit far. Let’s do this.   

Buffalo: Maybe one of the best examples of an “Uhh, why did they put them there?” team in the NFL. As Willis McGahee once said, Buffalo has nothing but an Applebee’s, a Dave & Busters and ugly women. Well, maybe it makes up for these deficiencies with the charm and security of a small town, right? Wrong. According to city reports, Buffalo has a high crime rate, an aging population and noticeable poverty issues. And yeah, it’s really damn cold. Sorry, C.J. Spiller. Look on the bright side, maybe they’ll move the team to…nevermind.   

Miami: Don’t worry, Robbie, I come in peace on this one. Miami is one of the few cities that will get a completely positive review in this post. Yes, there is the minor drawback of Rosetta Stone fees, but those are easily overcome by a tropical environment full of versatile options. If you’re into the downtown nightlife, go after a swanky waterfront abode and prepare to frequent Ocean Drive. If you’re more laid back, try one of the surrounding communities and spend your non-football days aimlessly wandering the picturesque waters of South Florida on your brand new Hatteras.   

New England: We’ll credit the Patriots to Boston. Boston is a cold and unfriendly place where Frank Costello is likely plotting to have you killed at all times. If your name has an “R” in it, you will never hear it pronounced correctly for the entirety of your stay there. Step out of line, and your failures will be stenciled into the mind of the public with weekly hate columns from Bill Simmons. Also, no matter how much the city pretends to like you, there will always be a free drink at the bar reserved for a short, balding Dustin Pedroia and not you. A bitter reminder of who the real stars of Boston are.   

New York (Jets and Giants): Many will probably split away from me here. New York City, the place of glitz, glamor, fame. Not for me. Sorry, but I’m no fan of the land of concrete and claustrophobia. Yes, New York is a town where an athlete can virtually take over the city with America’s largest spotlight. But when was the last time a football player actually did this? Yankees do it all the time. Mets did it in 1986. New Yorkers are still convinced that King James will do it eventually. You’re not Joe Namath.  

The days of Broadway Joe are long gone.

Baltimore: By all accounts except for one, Baltimore seems like a nice place to live. That one account is former Oriole Aubrey Huff who referred to Baltimore as a “horses**t town” in November 2007. He also trashed the city’s nightlife although many say that he was targeting Baltimore strip clubs, and not the nightlife in general. He did formerly live in Tampa, the mecca of $30 lap dances. Regardless, Baltimore seems like a nice place and it is good enough to catch my seal of approval.  

Cincinatti: This will surely piss off loyal Casualtist Brad Crone, but posts like this are bound to have that affect on people. Cincinatti is cold. Really cold. Bengals? No thanks.  

Cleveland: See above.  

Pittsburgh: I’ve been to Pennsylvania once, and I was too young to remember being there. However, my mom occasionally describes the trip and does so with a scrunched up “wow, that was awful” look on her face. My mom refers to things as being “gross” pretty regularly, but seldom with the tenacity that she fires off when Pittsburgh or the Steelers are mentioned. Not to mention the painted dirt playing surface that will greet you as you take the field at a stadium named after “fancy ketchup.” 

Houston: Houston is a decent southern sports town that occasionally surprises visitors with its giant size. Texas is a great state to play football in, but there is no secret that this is the inferior of the two Texas options available. The bright side of this is Galveston. The downside is larger. 

Indianapolis: When one pictures Indiana, they typically envision a curly headed white dude banging a basketball off of a makeshift backboard that has been nailed to the side of a barn. Does this sound like the glamorous NFL locale that you have dreamed of your entire life? No. Even your football stadium now looks like an old school basketball field house. Why? Because they wish the Colts were another basketball team. In fact, Indianapolis may be one Peyton Manning retirement away from making the Colts an Arena Ball team, and formally initiating the switch between Conseco Fieldhouse and Lucas Oil Stadium. 

Jacksonville: Ah, a nice warm Florida town conveniently located on the banks of the St. John’s River. I’m going to love this place, right? Eh, maybe. While Jacksonville does have numerous qualities that match my criteria (weather, nice suburbs, water), it also has other conflicting reports. Like the commonly filed complaint that the town smells like R. Kelly’s teen room (read: piss), and the well-known fact that you probably played in front of more fans during a regular season high school game. Oh well, Jacksonville gets a pass, but it is an uncertain one. 

Nashville: Allow me to express my previously mentioned bias when I say HELL YES. The Titans would be an amazing team to play for. Great city/area that incorporates the entire country music industry and an extremely unique and expansive nightlife. Ever heard of Carrie Underwood, Taylor Swift or Julianne Hough? Well they’re great looking country music singers who will probably be attracted to you and your football playing ways. Or stay more low key and go after a girl from Vanderbilt University who will show you more family money than any general manager can dream of. Dammit, I should have been born more athletic. 

Carrie Underwood would like to welcome you to Nashville.

Denver: I’m sure Denver is a lovely place for the few months out of the year when it is not a complete skyscraper of an icebox. The problem is that more than half of the football season takes place once the city is beginning to freeze over. There are some of the country’s most famous ski resort towns nearby, but you’re a professional football player and the last place you belong is on a pair of skis. Especially since you’re probably from either Florida, Texas or Southern California. There is also an overwhelming chance that you will be the punchline of many episiodes of “South Park.” 

Kansas City: A city that just kind of shoots off an indifferent kind of feeling. No, Kansas City doesn’t hit the depths of a Buffalo, Oakland or Detroit, but it isn’t an ideal place to live either. Arrowhead Stadium is one of the most hideous pieces of stadium architecture ever invented and the occasional 4 P.M. Chiefs game on CBS has about the same effect as Ambien. 

Oakland: Where do I begin? If San Francisco is the Hollywood of California’s Bay Area, Oakland is definitely its San Fernando Valley. Except instead of porn, Oakland specializes in crime and being a generally terrible place to live. You’ll have to deal with Al Davis and play in front of fans who would pass for serial killers if they wern’t sitting inside one of the NFL’s most awful stadiums. Oakland is the birthplace of Rocky Road ice cream which gives it minor cool points, but there is an overwhelming chance that you will get shot or be an earthquake victim before you try any of it. 

Screenshot from an Oakland tourism commercial.

San Diego: Ah, what a difference 492.12 miles can make. San Diego is one of the most beautiful cities in America and an overall fantastic place to live. It is a city that is perfectly spread out, is famous for its amazing weather and has a surplus of attractive blondes running around. It could honestly be difficult to find a better city to be a professional athlete in without passing on to the afterlife. If it’s good enough for Ron Burgundy, it’s good enough for me. 

Dallas: Scratch that last thought. There is a better city in which to be a professional football player and that city is Dallas. Dallas is not the civic masterpiece that San Diego represents, but you are a Cowboy and that is all that matters. I don’t believe that there is a better sports franchise in America to be a member of. It doesn’t matter if you are a third-string quarterback, you have a star on your helmet and therefore you are iconic. 

Philadelphia: A city that takes pride in its toughness. This is really a synonym for admitting that it is an awful place to reside. It’s probably not good that the city molds itself after Rocky Balboa, the fictional prize fighter who ends up broke. One mistake and the fans will likely chase you out of town as if you wanted to be there in the first place. To be fair, Philadelphia does have much brighter things to offer though like cheesesteaks and…uhh…cheeseteaks. 

Washington, D.C.: A visit to D.C. is enjoyable for roughly 30 minutes. Living there seems like an unbearable task. Also, Redskins fans far too often get a mysterious pass, but they are some of the worst fans in football. Non-existent when things are bad, in your face and obnoxious when things are decent. Add weather and embarrassing ownership into the recipe, and you have one dreadful destination. 

Chicago: My dad says that Chicago is a giant city without any of the flare or intrigue that a giant city typically includes. My dad has been to Chicago, I haven’t. I do know that Chicago is one of the most politically corrupt cities in a country full off politically corrupt cities. I also know that I once wrote a 10-page research paper on modern street gangs in America and spent hours reading about the Gangster Disciples in Chicago. This will sour your taste for a place quickly. 

Detroit: Picking on Detroit right now is kind of like stealing crutches from an injured old man and then repeatedly beating him over the head with them. Once a thriving factory town, Detroit no longer looks like something that belongs in America. I’ve heard before that Tiger Stadium is symbolic of Detroit’s path as a city. Tiger Stadium was demolished in September 2009. 

Symbol of the city.

Green Bay: You lost me at “frozen tundra.” Green Bay seems to have the small town charm that is lost in almost every other NFL city. It is home to Lambeau Field, one of the last pieces of old NFL memories still being used today. It has fans that are beyond loyal and being a Packer in Green Bay is likely one of the biggest status claims in the NFL. But Green Bay is cold, very cold, and I simply cannot support that. Sorry, I’m sure it’s a nice place in July. 

Minneapolis: See above. Seems like a nice enough place. Spectacular lakes, friendly people. The cold is a deal breaker. 

Atlanta: A moderate choice for decent locale. Atlanta has some nice suburbs that could make the hustle of the city more bearable. It’s tough to give this city my approval because I’m so accustomed to dreading the drive through it on my way to somewhere else.

Charlotte: Another moderate pass. Charlotte seems like a nice enough town from what I’ve seen of it (read: their airport). North Carolina does get cold though, so that could be a bit of a detractor.

New Orleans: A fun place to visit and not remember visiting. Not a home. Sorry, Drew Brees, I know you’re playing up the New Orleans savior deal right now, but you really need to stop pretending that you wouldn’t rather be in San Diego.

Tampa: I told you this would be biased, and now we come to Tampa, my hometown. There’s a reason why the vast majority of athletes who spend any time with a Tampa team end up moving here permanently. That reason is that Tampa is freaking awesome. Tony Kornheiser and Tim Brown hate Tampa. Kornheiser is a curmudgeon and Brown was always overrated. Tampa is a delightful port town with plenty of things to do and a low cost of living. That means that as an athlete, your millions will go further here than almost anywhere else. Think a bayfront house with an endless supply of sunshine, fine cigars and a luxury boat docked nearby.

Greatest city on Earth...according to me.

Glendale: A community of golf resorts and solid nightlife of course gets the nod from me. There’s not much to dislike about this area. Tempe is nearby, meaning that you are close to the home of Arizona State University, one of the country’s most notorious schools for parties and gorgeous coeds. Stick around for the spring and take in the Cactus League.

St. Louis: A great city to play baseball, not so much football. St. Louis kind of falls in the “ehh” category in which Kansas City resides. Plus side: You live in the home of Budweiser. Down side: You live in St. Louis.

San Francisco: By all accounts, San Francisco is a picturesque city to visit and a decent place to live. But you are an NFL player, and studies have shown that you are more likely to be both socially and fiscally conservative. Being a conservative in San Francisco is kind of like being a liberal in rural Alabama. As Leo DiCaprio would say, “You don’t need me to tell you you’re f****d.”

Seattle: It rains a lot in Seattle and not in a good “yay, this afternoon thunderstorm is so refreshing” kind of way, but rather in a “wow, this is depressing, I’m either going to kill myself or write mumbling grunge rock songs all day” kind of way. It is a shame because this would probably be a nice town if it wasn’t for its Londonesque ways. It is also home to great fans and beautiful scenery. But sunshine is a necessity, and so Seattle is a no go.

I'm still not convinced this is a real picture.



Filed under Uncategorized

9 responses to “NFL Cities That Suck (And A Few That Don’t)

  1. Corey Menozzi

    yes Bryan you are biased but i do agree Tampa is the best place ever

  2. A must read for any soon-to-be NFL superstar, or any North East Coaster who needs his ego bumped down a few notches… That said, I have to weigh in on a few places.

    Miami: Greatest city on Earth, let alone the United States. Comparing it to another locale in Florida would be like comparing Ruth to Phil Rizzuto under the premise that they’re both Yankee greats.

    Tampa: What’s the artsy, hipster district called? Last time I was there, I felt like I was gonna get mugged (and it’s not like I’ve ever felt that way in Miami). Great Greek food, though.

    Green Bay: Actually was there as part of a Midwest summer vacation. Needless to say, this is the only family vacation we’d file under “unqualified disaster.” We did see Brett Favre, though, and got to meet one of the old ’50s lineman. As I recall, he was dying of throat cancer and couldn’t speak.

    Cleveland: They still call it “The Mistake By The Lake,” correct?

    New York and Boston: You’re f***in’ nuts. Boston gets a pass for the history alone, and New York is swarming with hot Puerto Rican babes and Rex Ryan. Good enough for me.

    San Francisco: My parents are violently nodding their heads. Great trail mix town: fruits, flakes and nuts. Bang up weather, though, unless you visit during the middle of summer. In which case it’s 50 and raining. Bizarre.

    Seattle: Been there once and it was sunny and beautiful. Bonus points for Pearl Jam association. Minus points for me catching the only 3 “sunny and beautiful” days in the last 10 years.

    Chicago: One of my favorite cities, though I preface this by saying that I’ve never been in winter. Great food. Great, great deep dish pizza. Bonus points for Pearl Jam association – saw them at Lollapalooza four summers ago. Minus points for me almost dying after 11 hours in the same spot… in 104 degree heat and boxed in by 150,000
    other Pearl Jam fans.

    Nashville: Agree 100 percent. Shoe-in for top 5 NFL city. Shoutout to The Cooker. Also, solid music scene even if you’re not a redneck.

    Baltimore: Pretty sure they’re battling an inner-city drug epidemic and violent gang warfare, but I could be thinking of another Baltimore. Ever seen “The Wire”?

    Philadelphia: Agreed. Deserves the Canada treatment. i.e. It sucks.

    Glendale: Another beautiful city, but damn, the dramatic temperature changes really throw you off. Played golf in the desert a couple of times. Felt a heat stroke coming on at about 3, and then needed a jacket and windshield for the cart when the sun went down. Negative points for ’87 and ’03 Fiasco Bowls in nearby Tempe.

    Oakland: Surprisingly beautiful for the entirety of its 500-yard border with Berkeley. Great pizza joint called Zachary’s. The rest, as you say, is an abominable hell hole. Known best for Al Davis and a rap group called N.W.A (look up the unabbreviated name… Uh… yeah). Plus, it looks like one giant oil rig. My dad won’t let my mom drive through.

    • bholt11

      Ladies and gentlemen, renowned avid traveler, Robbie Hilson.

      New York and Boston: I knew that I would get plenty of disagreements here. This is where major bias kicks in. Not a mega-city kind of guy in most places, although I am a big fan of Los Angeles. I’ve been to New York, but never Boston. I’ve heard mixed reviews from many about it, and it typically hits the line of former residents hate it, and visitors love it. I would like to visit.

      Chicago: Another place that I’ve never been, but would like to see if for no other reason than to go to a game at Wrigley. If all works out, I’ll be on a ballpark trip after graduation and it will be a crucial stop.

      Nashville: Taking a four day weekend for next season’s Florida-Vandy game and can’t wait.

      Glendale: Almost mentioned the weather downside that you brought up, but left it out.

      Oakland: You read my mind with N.W.A., I was looking for a clever mention of them to close out the description, but passed on it and moved on instead.

    • bholt11

      Oh, and I’m assuming that you’re talking about Ybor City in your Tampa comment. Ybor tends to be our way of scaring away some tourists. The best lesson I can give you about visiting Tampa is that if you see a sign that reads “Historical District,” you need to get the hell out of there.

      • Ybor City. Bingo. And that’s funny about “historical districts” because they use the same trick in Miami. Same goes for naming things after Martin Luther King. The poor man’s been through enough – he doesn’t need his name plastered on every rundown park in Liberty City, too.

        As for Wrigley, along with Augusta National, it’s one of the only sports venues I’ve been to where seeing it in person just blows away the already pristine TV version. Absolutely stunning to the point of looking surreal. The Rose Bowl turf is like this, too. Flawless.

        Fenway, on the other hand, is the kind of grungy pit you’d expect. Still awesome, but in a different way. Stay out of the bathrooms.

  3. Pingback: “Panic Mode” and Other Google Trends: The Week in Review, Redux « Sports Casualties

  4. Kyle

    Dude. Seattle actually doesn’t rain as much as everyone thinks. It still rains, don’t get me wrong, but at last check, it was something like 37th in annual rainfall behind cities like Houston, Chicago, and Dallas. We certainly have a lot of gray and “gloomy” days, so I’ll give you that. But we allow people to think that Seattle rains all the time and it sucks so people won’t move here. And I’d venture to say that Qwest Field is the loudest outdoor stadium in the entire NFL.

    • bholt11

      First off, no doubt in my mind about Qwest Field. The place has an absolute college stadium buzz about it that isn’t heard in NFL stadiums much anymore.

      As far as rainfall, I won’t get too into it because you’re obviously familiar with Seattle and I am not. Same with plenty of the other cities that I mention above. But I think that annual rainfall can be a bit deceiving. I’m sure Tampa (where I’m from) and Miami (Robbie) have higher rainfall totals than Seattle. But that’s because Florida rainfall comes in roughly two hour daily stretches of heavy downpour thunderstorms during the summer afternoons and then it’s sunny the rest of the day. The storms rack up tons of rainfall but keep the rest of the day enjoyable and sunny.

      Again, I was trying to catch the “gloomy” factor. I have heard it’s a wonderful place, however, and I really look forward to visiting it sometime. Maybe during next summer’s ballpark trip.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s